I was pleasantly surprised when the founder of Jewelry Subscription, Lisa Martino, reached out to me to ask if I would review a box for our blog and I jumped at the chance. I mean, I really, really love jewelry. I am kind of a big deal at Baublebar (seriously- they called me and asked me my opinions on things for over an hour) but I’m totally into trying new things.

The way that Jewelry Subscription works is that you take an extensive survey about your jewelry preferences: Do you like gold/silver? Bigger pieces or delicate jewelry? etc. Once you have completed your preferences, jewelry will be selected specifically for you! This isn’t the type of box where the same jewelry is sent to everyone.

The pricing of the different boxes will vary, depending on how many pieces you would like per month, but all choices are an incredible deal! This is definitely one of the lowest-cost jewelry subscription services out there right now.

  • Monthly membership for 1 piece of jewelry: $16.19 for first month, $17.99 after
  • Monthly membership for 2-3 pieces: $22.49 for first month, $24.99 after
  • 1 year membership for 1 piece of jewelry/month: $179.99
  • 1 year membership for 2-3 pieces of jewelry/month $249.99

Shipping is always included with your subscription.

There is also a Special Occasion Membership which includes 3 pieces of jewelry shipped fo 6 special occasions specified by you for $199.99/year. To the guys out there… you don’t have to worry about forgetting your anniversary ever again! Jewelry Subscription has got you covered! 🙂

The only downside of this box is that if you do not like the piece/pieces of jewelry you receive, there are no returns. However, if you receive pieces of jewelry that aren’t quite your style, you can always contact Jewelry Subscription and better clarify your likes/dislikes so future boxes will be perfect!

Full disclosure: I did receive a box of jewelry containing pieces of jewelry that were not my style at all. It was so easy to work with Jewelry Subscription and they sent me the following pieces, which I absolutely adore! 

Let’s see what I got!


I received the box with 2-3 pieces of jewelry. They came in a hot pink mailer (not technically a box, but it’s just easier to call it a box!), all wrapped very well. Two of my pieces came in these nice black boxes and the other was wrapped very carefully in bubble wrap.

And onto the pieces in more detail!


I love this gold necklace! I think it will look great against a black shirt or dress! I think it can be dressed up or down, so I am a fan!


I also really love these dainty gold midi rings! I love that they sent me 6 little rings that I can wear in different combinations (and mix and match with other rings I own!) I can’t stress enough how much I love these! I feel like during the summer months, it’s easier to wear these dainty rings with a casual sun dress and look effortlessly great.

This gold bracelet is definitely a statement piece. I can’t immediately think of what I will wear it with, but I do really like it. The bracelet has a hinge on the back so it opens and closes over your wrist. It’s stunning!


Final Grade: A

I really liked the jewelry I received in from Jewelry Subscription! I’m really excited to wear the necklace sometime soon. I need to figure out what shirt/dress to wear with it! And the midi rings are so pretty and delicate.

If you are interested in receiving a styled jewelry subscription every month, click here for the subscription options! And click here to Like Jewelry Subscription on Facebook!

Press sample received in exchange for an honest review

A self-proclaimed beauty junkie/hoarder with a serious Sephora problem. After years with Birchbox, she now has a subscription box problem as well. Her free time is a mixed combination of cats, TV, and finally trying to figure out how to do her hair.

Comments are closed.